Faith and Doubt

in a Culture of Disbelief

  • Home
  • About
  • Milestones
  • Contact

What Carson Said about Muslims

September 22, 2015 5 Comments

Share this post:

Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on LinkedInShare on Email

Ben CarsonMark Twain once remarked, “It ain’t those parts of the Bible that I can’t understand that bother me, it is the parts that I do understand.” When Dr. Ben Carson pointed out the static between the Koran and the Constitution, I think he was saying something similar. Pundits critique him as narrow (read “simplistic”) and compliment themselves as plural (read: “sophisticated”) However, democracy is not an academic exercise where all ideas are equal; it’s the fruit of a culture shaped by certain kinds of convictions.

Media Hypocrisy?

In the guise of separating church and state, cultural elites have been purging public life of anything that smacks of Christianity. Whereas, calling out Islam is considered a no-no. But Carson’s statement raises concern that, around the globe, the practice of Islam works against the grain of democracy. Carson’s aim, ironically, is to protect principles of democracy which include Muslims.

French scholar Alexis de Tocqueville observed:

[Christianity] in America … must be regarded as the foremost of the political institutions of that country; for if it does not impart a taste for freedom, it facilitates the use of it.

You need not subscribe to the U.S. being a Christian nation (now or once upon a time) to see the historic importance of Christian sensibility to the American experiment.  While Jefferson, who wrote many of our founding documents, had a pick-and-chose approach to Christian doctrine, he and the founding fathers framed our society presuming upon the categories of human dignity, equality, and transcendent purpose supplied by the Judeo-Christian heritage.

Is Carson discriminating?

Some may say, “I know plenty of Muslims who only want to practice their religion and raise their children in peace.” I have witnessed the same. However, in order to discharge the office of president in keeping with E Pluribus Unum, a Muslim would need to set aside not minor doctrines, but the very external and immanent nature of Islam. In Kenya and parts of Europe, Muslims aggressively and assertively influence culture. More than private morality is in their crosshairs. Of course Carson is discriminating in terms of ideals. The law itself discriminates when it comes to running for president, e.g. no one under thirty-five may run.  Is youth more a threat to democracy than Sharia Law?

What about parts of the Bible that contradict American plurality?

Others may point to Christianity with the same objection–that the Old Testament presumes upon a theocratic form of government, for instance. Actually, the New Testament reframes the principles of the Old Testament apart from theocracy. “Render unto Caesar what is Caesar’s,” Jesus said. Paul tells the Roman church to be subject to the law of the land (Rom. 13:1).

Again, it is not PC to say it, but certain beliefs line-up with and foster the principles of democracy and others do not. Paradoxically, Christian doctrines like grace and freedom so evident in the constitution make us vulnerable to potential threats to grace and freedom–to people who despise such doctrines as weak but capitalize on them as opportunists. Ideas have consequences.

“What we suffer from today is humility in the wrong place. Modesty has moved from the organ of ambition and settled upon the organ of conviction, where it was never meant to be. A man was meant to be doubtful about himself, but undoubting about the truth; this has been exactly reversed” (Chesterton).  

Related

Filed Under: News & Culture

Subscribe to Faith and Doubt

Subscribe to Faith and Doubt today and receive a free copy of Milestones.

Comments

  1. Howard Filston says

    September 22, 2015 at 11:43 AM

    Right on! One only need to look around the world to confirm that countries in which Islam predominates do not allow the freedoms that are inherent in American society, freedoms that stem from the idea that these freedoms are God-given and not an entitlement from a government. Even in parts of Europe in which the percentage of Muslims is significant, there is considerable conflict between Sharia law and the secular law.

    On the other hand, Ben could have been a bit more self-protective in his answer. For years in America Catholics were unlikely to succeed to the presidency for fear that the Pope would unduly influence a Catholic president. However, Catholicism as a Christian religion is not out of line with America’s principles; not so Sharia. An answer that would have caused less commotion would have been to say that he would have to have some solid assurance that the individual running for president would not impose Sharia Law. But Ben is not a politician and so doesn’t think as one does. He says what he believes; the left-wing media knows it; so they ask him questions they wouldn’t ask anyone else.

  2. Cliff Foreman says

    September 23, 2015 at 12:56 PM

    Actually, it took the American church a while to harmonize democracy with Christianity. And as late as 1960, JFK had to reassure the American people that he could be president and not take orders from the Pope. So if Islam can be seen as out of sync with democracy, Christianity can be seen that way, too. Perhaps Ben Carson should disqualify himself from the Presidency. Look at the county clerk in Kentucky.

  3. Bobby Eric Brown says

    September 23, 2015 at 1:11 PM

    As a believer of the “proof is in the pudding”, we can look at the numerous Muslim led governments around the world for indications of their application of sharia law and its effects on the Muslim populations. Savagery in the execution of sharia law is totally incompatible with the American ideal of freedom, not to mention Christianity. Dr. Carson is being vilified for being asked an opinion, and responding with his opinion.

  4. Tim Filston says

    September 23, 2015 at 1:18 PM

    Thanks for your comment Cliff. Carson should be disqualified if he sees the presidency as a means of building a Christian theocracy. But I don’t think he does, and I think he’s just pointing out the implicit theocratic underpinnings of Islam, namely Sharia Law. He should he have said it without personalizing it to individual Muslims, making it sound like religion is a litmus test. That would have been less divisive.

  5. Warren Sinor says

    September 23, 2015 at 2:39 PM

    Ideas do have consequences. The Chesterton quote “ A man was meant to be doubtful about himself, but undoubting about the truth; this has been exactly reversed” speaks to a daily frustration and a daily creep. I find myself both repulsed by it and daily more accepting of it. The cold splash of water from a respected man of thought and conviction is refreshing. Sometimes we are collectively looking for those not caught up in the madness and with the courage and desire to express their heart, mind and soul. Your article is reassuring. Thanks.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Who is Behind Faith and Doubt?

Tim FilstonTriplets+1 Dad. Smokies trout stalker. Spandex warrior. Comforting the afflicted and afflicting the comfortable.
More about Tim.

FacebookLinkedInTwitter

Get updates from Faith and Doubt by email!


Subscribe to Faith and Doubt today and receive a free copy of Milestones.

Main Topics

  • Personal Growth
  • Relationships
  • Leadership
  • News & Culture
  • Tough Questions
  • Great Reads

Latest Tweets

  • Time doesn't automatically heal all wounds. It only dulls them until we start doing this.... www.faithanddoubt.com/personal…

    November 18, 2022 11:27 AM

  • Turning your past into compost www.faithanddoubt.com/personal…

    November 17, 2022 5:15 PM

  • How to make peace, not just keep it www.faithanddoubt.com/leadersh…

    November 10, 2022 11:46 AM

Facebook

Facebook

RSS Featured Links

  • Deserved the Flood, Received the Ark
  • Hemingway Chased His Dreams to Their Bitter End
  • Sunday Morning Songs for Kids: A Free TGC Playlist
  • Savior or Stoics? Why Modern Men Look for Spiritual Wisdom Outside the Church
  • Will God Provide for Your Needs?

Latest Tweets

  • Time doesn't automatically heal all wounds. It only dulls them until we start doing this.... www.faithanddoubt.com/personal…

    November 18, 2022 11:27 AM

  • Turning your past into compost www.faithanddoubt.com/personal…

    November 17, 2022 5:15 PM

RSS Leadership tips from Tony Morgan

Recent Posts

  • Turning your past into compost
  • How to make peace, not just keep it
  • Should you make kids go to church? 

all content © 2023 by Tim Filston | Design by Robin Cornett